I write educational posts on buying your home for the first time. I even posted my homebuying book at r/NewbHomebuyer if you want to check it out

Opinions on "how much can I afford?" gets tossed around a lot.

A lender will tell you one number, Dave Ramsey will tell you another, and the 30% gross rule lands somewhere in between.

I ran the numbers on a $500,000 home across all 50 states, with 5% down, .25% mortgage insurance factor, no other debt, and today's average 30-year rate at 6.44%.

Here's what each school of thought says you'd need to make.

Part 1: Minimum for a lender

This is the bare minimum income you'd need to squeak through underwriting at a 49.99% back-end DTI with no other debts, which is the ceiling Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will allow on a conventional loan. Approvable does not mean affordable.

State Minimum Income
NJ $101,302
IL $100,102
TX $99,801
CT $98,401
NE $97,901
NH $95,501
VT $95,201
KS $95,101
NY $94,300
IA $93,500
WI $93,200
RI $92,300
OH $92,200
MI $92,000
SD $91,800
FL $91,500
OK $91,400
PA $91,100
ME $89,599
MN $89,099
MA $89,099
AK $87,999
MO $87,599
MD $87,499
ND $87,199
GA $86,999
MS $86,499
KY $86,399
AR $86,199
IN $85,899
MT $85,799
NM $85,799
OR $85,499
NC $85,399
LA $85,299
WA $85,099
VA $84,798
CA $84,498
CO $84,298
TN $84,098
AZ $83,798
ID $83,098
SC $83,098
WY $82,798
WV $82,398
DE $82,298
NV $82,198
UT $81,998
AL $81,798
HI $79,497

Part 2: The minimum income needed for the Ramsey 25% net take-home rule

This one factors in property taxes, homeowners insurance, state income tax, federal tax, FICA, and a 6% 401k contribution to get to a true net number. It's why a state like TX (no state income tax) shakes out differently than UT (4.65%), even when the housing costs are similar.

State Minimum Income
NJ $360,805
CT $325,250
VT $323,233
NE $321,308
IL $320,006
WI $308,993
NY $308,756
KS $305,502
MN $305,335
IA $300,567
RI $296,527
TX $293,640
ME $292,363
OR $291,064
OK $286,844
MI $286,574
CA $283,712
OH $283,635
MA $279,724
NH $279,161
PA $277,893
MD $277,538
GA $274,106
MO $273,545
HI $273,042
NM $272,168
MT $272,168
MS $270,581
AR $269,081
VA $267,923
SD $267,142
FL $266,162
KY $265,789
SC $264,750
NC $263,446
LA $263,099
DE $262,759
ND $262,207
ID $262,089
CO $260,263
IN $260,088
WV $256,671
AK $254,798
AL $254,052
UT $253,290
AZ $250,725
WA $245,378
TN $242,130
WY $237,907
NV $235,958

Part 3: The 30%-of-your-gross rule

A popular middle-ground rule of thumb. It doesn't account for taxes or savings. just a flat 30% of your gross income going toward the housing payment.

State Minimum Income
NJ $168,803
IL $166,803
TX $166,303
CT $163,969
NE $163,136
NH $159,136
VT $158,636
KS $158,469
NY $157,136
IA $155,803
WI $155,303
RI $153,803
OH $153,636
MI $153,303
SD $152,969
FL $152,469
OK $152,303
PA $151,803
ME $149,303
MA $148,469
MN $148,469
AK $146,636
MO $145,969
MD $145,803
ND $145,303
GA $144,969
MS $144,136
KY $143,969
AR $143,636
IN $143,136
NM $142,969
MT $142,969
OR $142,469
NC $142,303
LA $142,136
WA $141,803
VA $141,303
CA $140,803
CO $140,469
TN $140,136
AZ $139,636
ID $138,469
SC $138,469
WY $137,969
WV $137,303
DE $137,136
NV $136,969
UT $136,636
AL $136,303
HI $132,469

Part 4: Combined so you can see it all side by side

State Lender 30% Gross 25% Net
NJ $101,302 $168,803 $360,805
IL $100,102 $166,803 $320,006
TX $99,801 $166,303 $293,640
CT $98,401 $163,969 $325,250
NE $97,901 $163,136 $321,308
NH $95,501 $159,136 $279,161
VT $95,201 $158,636 $323,233
KS $95,101 $158,469 $305,502
NY $94,300 $157,136 $308,756
IA $93,500 $155,803 $300,567
WI $93,200 $155,303 $308,993
RI $92,300 $153,803 $296,527
OH $92,200 $153,636 $283,635
MI $92,000 $153,303 $286,574
SD $91,800 $152,969 $267,142
FL $91,500 $152,469 $266,162
OK $91,400 $152,303 $286,844
PA $91,100 $151,803 $277,893
ME $89,599 $149,303 $292,363
MN $89,099 $148,469 $305,335
MA $89,099 $148,469 $279,724
AK $87,999 $146,636 $254,798
MO $87,599 $145,969 $273,545
MD $87,499 $145,803 $277,538
ND $87,199 $145,303 $262,207
GA $86,999 $144,969 $274,106
MS $86,499 $144,136 $270,581
KY $86,399 $143,969 $265,789
AR $86,199 $143,636 $269,081
IN $85,899 $143,136 $260,088
MT $85,799 $142,969 $272,168
NM $85,799 $142,969 $272,168
OR $85,499 $142,469 $291,064
NC $85,399 $142,303 $263,446
LA $85,299 $142,136 $263,099
WA $85,099 $141,803 $245,378
VA $84,798 $141,303 $267,923
CA $84,498 $140,803 $283,712
CO $84,298 $140,469 $260,263
TN $84,098 $140,136 $242,130
AZ $83,798 $139,636 $250,725
ID $83,098 $138,469 $262,089
SC $83,098 $138,469 $264,750
WY $82,798 $137,969 $237,907
WV $82,398 $137,303 $256,671
DE $82,298 $137,136 $262,759
NV $82,198 $136,969 $235,958
UT $81,998 $136,636 $253,290
AL $81,798 $136,303 $254,052
HI $79,497 $132,469 $273,042

one other thought that people will be sure to mention: median home prices in each state are different too. A $500k home in TX is very different from a $500k home in Hawaii. Should be a given, but people will mention it anyway.

Hope it helps!

Sam

I write educational posts on buying your home for the first time. I even posted my homebuying book at r/NewbHomebuyer if you want to check it out

Originally shared by u/SamTMortgageBroker in r/NewbHomebuyer — view the original thread.